Wylie played his first career game in round 11 of the 1934 season vs University. He scored two tries on debut to help his team win 30–5.[2] He played in South Sydney's 6–19 loss to Eastern Suburbs in the Semi Finals.
In 1935, Wylie scored two tries in a round 14 win over Balmain.[3] The following round, he scored three tries agwainst Newtown, helping his side win 21–13.[4][5] South Sydney advanced to the grand final, though Wylie missed the game due to a nagging elbow injury.[6]
Wylie played his final game in round 6 of the 1936 season against North Sydney.[7] He concluded his career with 7 tries in 15 appearances.[citation needed]