List of Cleveland Browns starting quarterbacks

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The Cleveland Browns are a professional American football team in Cleveland, Ohio. The Browns compete in the National Football League (NFL) as a member of the American Football Conference (AFC) North division.

Since joining the NFL in 1950, the Browns have had 69 quarterbacks start at least one game. Pro Football Hall of Famer Otto Graham led the Browns to three NFL championships in their first six seasons in the league.

After resuming play in 1999 following a three-year suspension of operations, the franchise has been notable for its instability at the quarterback position.[1][2][3] From 1999 through the mid 2025 season, the team has had 42 players start at quarterback, with only three seasons (2001 with Tim Couch, 2019 and 2020 with Baker Mayfield) in which the same quarterback started every game.[1][4]

The early era of the NFL and American football in general was not conducive to passing the football, with the forward pass not being legalized until the early 1900s and not fully adopted for many more years.[5] Although the quarterback position has historically been the one to receive the snap and thus handle the football on every offensive play,[6] the importance of the position during this era was limited by various rules, like having to be five yards behind the line of scrimmage before a forward pass could be attempted.[7] These rules and the tactical focus on rushing the ball limited the importance of the quarterback position while enhancing the value of different types of backs, such as the halfback and the fullback.[8] Some of these backs were considered triple-threat men, capable of rushing, passing or kicking the football, making it common for multiple players to attempt a pass during a game.[9]

As rules changed and the NFL began adopting a more pass-centric approach to offensive football, the importance of the quarterback position grew.[7][8] Beginning in 1950, total wins and losses by a team's starting quarterback were tracked.[10] Prior to 1950, the Browns had numerous players identified as playing the quarterback position. However, the combination of unreliable statistics in the early era of the NFL and the differences in the early quarterback position make tracking starts by quarterbacks impractical for this timeframe.

Starters per season

Otto Graham (1946–1955)
Brian Sipe (1974–1983)
Bernie Kosar (1985–1993)
Tim Couch (1999–2003)
Colt McCoy (2010–2011)
Brandon Weeden (2012–2013)
Johnny Manziel (2014–2015)
Baker Mayfield (2018–2021)
Deshaun Watson (2022–2024)

The number of regular season games each player started during the season is listed to the right.

More information Season(s), Quarterback(s) ...
Season(s)Quarterback(s)
1950Otto Graham (12)
1951 Otto Graham (12)
1952 Otto Graham (12)
1953Otto Graham (11) / George Ratterman (1)
1954Otto Graham (12)
1955 Otto Graham (12)
1956Tommy O'Connell (5) / George Ratterman (4) / Babe Parilli (3)
1957Tommy O'Connell (9) / Milt Plum (3)
1958Milt Plum (12)
1959 Milt Plum (12)
1960 Milt Plum (12)
1961Milt Plum (13) / Len Dawson (1)
1962Jim Ninowski (7) / Frank Ryan (7)
1963Frank Ryan (13) / Jim Ninowski (1)
1964Frank Ryan (14)
1965Frank Ryan (12) / Jim Ninowski (2)
1966Frank Ryan (14)
1967Frank Ryan (13) / Gary Lane (1)
1968Bill Nelsen (11) / Frank Ryan (3)
1969Bill Nelsen (14)
1970Bill Nelsen (12) / Mike Phipps (1) / Don Gault (1)
1971Bill Nelsen (13) / Mike Phipps (1)
1972Mike Phipps (13) / Bill Nelsen (1)
1973Mike Phipps (14)
1974Mike Phipps (9) / Brian Sipe (5)
1975Mike Phipps (11) / Brian Sipe (2) / Will Cureton (1)
1976Brian Sipe (14) / Mike Phipps (2)
1977Brian Sipe (9) / Dave Mays (4) / Terry Luck (1)
1978Brian Sipe (16)
1979 Brian Sipe (16)
1980 Brian Sipe (16)
1981 Brian Sipe (16)
1982Brian Sipe (6) / Paul McDonald (3)
1983Brian Sipe (14) / Paul McDonald (2)
1984Paul McDonald (16)
1985Bernie Kosar (10) / Gary Danielson (6)
1986Bernie Kosar (16)
1987Bernie Kosar (12) / Jeff Christensen (2) / Gary Danielson (1)
1988Bernie Kosar (9) / Mike Pagel (4) / Don Strock (2) / Gary Danielson (1)
1989Bernie Kosar (16)
1990Bernie Kosar (13) / Mike Pagel (3)
1991Bernie Kosar (16)
1992Mike Tomczak (8) / Bernie Kosar (7) / Todd Philcox (1)
1993Bernie Kosar (7) / Vinny Testaverde (6) / Todd Philcox (3)
1994Vinny Testaverde (13) / Mark Rypien (3)
1995Vinny Testaverde (12) / Eric Zeier (4)
1996–1998Suspended operations
1999Tim Couch (14) / Ty Detmer (2)
2000Doug Pederson (8) / Tim Couch (7) / Spergon Wynn (1)
2001Tim Couch (16)
2002Tim Couch (14) / Kelly Holcomb (2)
2003Kelly Holcomb (8) / Tim Couch (8)
2004Jeff Garcia (10) / Luke McCown (4) / Kelly Holcomb (2)
2005Trent Dilfer (11) / Charlie Frye (5)
2006Charlie Frye (13) / Derek Anderson (3)
2007Derek Anderson (15) / Charlie Frye (1)
2008Derek Anderson (9) / Brady Quinn (3) / Ken Dorsey (3) / Bruce Gradkowski (1)
2009Brady Quinn (9) / Derek Anderson (7)
2010Colt McCoy (8) / Jake Delhomme (4) / Seneca Wallace (4)
2011Colt McCoy (13) / Seneca Wallace (3)
2012Brandon Weeden (15) / Thad Lewis (1)
2013Jason Campbell (8) / Brandon Weeden (5) / Brian Hoyer (3)
2014Brian Hoyer (13) / Johnny Manziel (2) / Connor Shaw (1)
2015Josh McCown (8) / Johnny Manziel (6) / Austin Davis (2)
2016Cody Kessler (8) / Robert Griffin III (5) / Josh McCown (3)
2017DeShone Kizer (15) / Kevin Hogan (1)
2018Baker Mayfield (13) / Tyrod Taylor (3)
2019Baker Mayfield (16)
2020Baker Mayfield (16)
2021Baker Mayfield (14) / Case Keenum (2) / Nick Mullens (1)
2022Jacoby Brissett (11) / Deshaun Watson (6)
2023Deshaun Watson (6) / Joe Flacco (5) / Dorian Thompson-Robinson (3) / P. J. Walker (2) / Jeff Driskel (1)
2024Jameis Winston (7) / Deshaun Watson (7) / Dorian Thompson-Robinson (2) / Bailey Zappe (1)
2025Shedeur Sanders (7) / Dillon Gabriel (6) / Joe Flacco (4)
Close

Most games started

Quarterbacks who have started for the Cleveland Browns from the team's first NFL season of 1950 to present. A player is credited with a win if he started the game and the team won that game, no matter if the player was injured or permanently removed after the first play from scrimmage. Only regular season games are included. The Browns' All-America Football Conference games from 1946 to 1949 are not included. The Browns did not field a team from 1996 to 1998.

Sorted by number of starts. Members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame in italics and most recent starter in bold.

More information Quarterback, Games started ...
Quarterback Games started Wins Losses Ties Winning pct.
Brian Sipe11257550.509
Bernie Kosar10553511.510
Frank Ryan7652222.697
Otto Graham7157131.810
Tim Couch5922370.373
Baker Mayfield5929300.492
Bill Nelsen5134161.676
Mike Phipps5124252.490
Milt Plum5133162.667
Derek Anderson3416180.471
Vinny Testaverde3116150.516
Paul McDonald218130.381
Colt McCoy216150.286
Brandon Weeden205150.250
Deshaun Watson199100.474
Charlie Frye196130.316
Brian Hoyer161060.625
DeShone Kizer150150.000
Tommy O'Connell141031.750
Kelly Holcomb12480.333
Brady Quinn12390.250
Jim Ninowski11560.455
Trent Dilfer11470.364
Jacoby Brissett11470.364
Josh McCown111100.091
Jeff Garcia10370.300
Joe Flacco9540.556
Gary Danielson8530.625
Mike Tomczak8440.500
Doug Pederson8170.125
Jason Campbell8170.125
Johnny Manziel8260.250
Cody Kessler8080.000
Mike Pagel7250.286
Seneca Wallace7160.143
Jameis Winston7250.286
Shedeur Sanders7340.429
Dillon Gabriel6150.167
George Ratterman5230.400
Todd Philcox5230.400
Robert Griffin III5140.200
Dorian Thompson-Robinson5140.200
Jake Delhomme4220.500
Dave Mays4130.250
Eric Zeier4130.250
Luke McCown4040.000
Babe Parilli3120.333
Mark Rypien3210.667
Ken Dorsey3030.000
Tyrod Taylor3111.500
Don Strock22001.000
Jeff Christensen2110.500
Ty Detmer2020.000
Austin Davis2020.000
Case Keenum22001.000
P. J. Walker2110.500
Don Gault11001.000
Gary Lane1010.000
Len Dawson11001.000
Spergon Wynn1010.000
Terry Luck1010.000
Will Cureton1010.000
Bruce Gradkowski1010.000
Thaddeus Lewis1010.000
Connor Shaw1010.000
Kevin Hogan1010.000
Nick Mullens1010.000
Jeff Driskel1010.000
Bailey Zappe1010.000
Close

Team career passing records

As of Week 18 of the 2024 NFL season.[11] Completion percentage and passer rating records are for players with at least 1500 pass attempts for the Browns.

  • Most yards: Brian Sipe – 23,713
  • Most touchdowns: Otto Graham – 174
  • Most interceptions: Brian Sipe – 149
  • Highest completion percentage: Baker Mayfield – 61.6%
  • Highest passer rating: Baker Mayfield – 87.8

Postseason

These Browns quarterbacks started during the postseason.

More information Season(s), Quarterback(s) ...
Season(s)Quarterback(s)
1950 Otto Graham (2–0)
1951Otto Graham (0–1)
1952 Otto Graham (0–1)
1953 Otto Graham (0–1)
1954Otto Graham (1–0)
1955 Otto Graham (1–0)
1957Tommy O'Connell (0–1)
1958Milt Plum (0–1)
1964Frank Ryan (1–0)
1965Frank Ryan (0–1)
1967 Frank Ryan (0–1)
1968Bill Nelsen (1–1)
1969 Bill Nelsen (1–1)
1971Bill Nelsen (0–1)
1972Mike Phipps (0–1)
1980Brian Sipe (0–1)
1982Paul McDonald (0–1)
1985Bernie Kosar (0–1)
1986Bernie Kosar (1–1)
1987 Bernie Kosar (1–1)
1988Don Strock (0–1)
1989Bernie Kosar (1–1)
1994Vinny Testaverde (1–1)
2002Kelly Holcomb (0–1)
2020Baker Mayfield (1–1)
2023Joe Flacco (0–1)
Close

Pro Bowl selections

These Browns starting quarterbacks have been selected to the Pro Bowl.[12]

More information Quarterback, Season(s) selected ...
QuarterbackSeason(s) selected
Otto Graham1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1954
Tommy O'Connell1957
Milt Plum1960, 1961
Frank Ryan1964, 1965, 1966
Bill Nelsen1969
Brian Sipe1980
Bernie Kosar1987
Derek Anderson2007
Shedeur Sanders2025
Close

See also

References

Related Articles

Wikiwand AI