In 2023, the story resurfaced widely on social media, sparking renewed speculation.[2] Some online discussions humorously or seriously proposed a link between the "deep toad" and the Loch Ness Monster, suggesting the mythical creature could be a giant amphibian, such as a Chinese giant salamander or a previously unknown species.[2]
This revived interest connected to broader, non-peer-reviewed theories about the loch's ecology, including the possibility of large eels or relict populations of ancient animals. A major environmental DNA (eDNA) survey of the loch led by New Zealand's University of Otago in 2018 found no genetic evidence of large prehistoric reptiles like plesiosaurs, sturgeon, catfish, or sharks. However, the research detected a "very significant amount of eel DNA" at nearly every sampling location. Geneticist Professor Neil Gemmell stated that while the data could not confirm the size of these eels, the sheer quantity of their DNA means the possibility of giant eels in Loch Ness and that such creatures could be behind monster sightings cannot be discounted.[3]