Love for All Seasons (film)

Reviewer Andrew Saroch of fareastfilms.com gave the film a rating of 4 out of 5 stars, writing, "With a bolshy heart beating within its frame that is resolutely Asian, ‘Love For All Seasons’ is a rom-com that refuses to be conventional. [...] ‘Love For All Seasons’ is a refreshing change from a cinematic staple and a reminder of the fact that To can impress no matter what genre he works within." The review concludes, "The concept may take a little getting used to, but ‘Love For All Seasons’ is a superior vehicle for Sammi Cheng and an enjoyable mixture of zany plot twists, comedy and romance. Difficult to describe and infectious throughout, this is an example of Hong Kong cinema playing to its localised strengths."^[7]

Reviewer Kozo of lovehkfilm.com wrote, "Johnnie To and Sammi Cheng usually equals a light, fun and surprisingly good time at the movies. Love For All Seasons is most definitely light, and it's even occasionally fun. But really, it's not that good."^[8]

Reviewer Derek Elley of Variety wrote, "Pic lacks the emotional undertow of its B.O. opponent, 'My Lucky Star,' but is overall better made and more accessible for Sinophile fest auds."^[9]

Reviewer Eugene of heroic-cinema.com wrote, "I really can’t say I didn’t enjoy Love for All Seasons – despite it being formualic [sic] and overly sentimental." The review concludes, "After all Love for All Seasons is an enjoyable film in its own right and another very cool film to join the ranks of some pretty decent films that seem to come out for Chinese New Year. Yes it is predictable. Yes it is overly sentimental. Still does not mean you cannot enjoy the film and put you in the right mood for the new year."

A review on rowereviews.com reads, "Conceptually and stylistically, Love For All Seasons has got to be one of the most manic film [sic] in all of Johnnie To's prolific oeuvre. Incorporating wuxia into the romantic comedy narrative structure, Love For All Seasons a high-concept comedy with a moderately perverse premise in which Playboy Louis Koo agrees to help a virginal martial arts guru master a technique that can only be learned by having one's heart broken. Injected with an energy that rivals even To's most dynamic action film, Love For All Seasons is in nearly in constant motion, matching its conceit with an infectious dynamism. Funny and charming, the conceptual absurdity is employed to reinforce the film's thematic intentions, exhibiting the elusivity of attempting to deconstruct affect. In Love For All Seasons, Love is portrayed as cognitively indiscernible, emotionally irrational, yet essential despite it remaining largely an emotion that exists outside of strict quantification or classification. A wild movie that moves with such vitality that it's hard not to appreciate its fervor".^[10]

Reviewer Ted Shen of chicagoreader.com wrote, "If Hong Kong comedy’s infinite capacity for outlandish plot turns, lowbrow humor, and shameless consumerism doesn’t wear you out, then you might be fitfully amused by this goofball item from the prolific team of Wai Ka-fai and Johnnie To."^[11]

A review on 2 Things @ Once called the film "Really fun." The review concludes, "Part quest for knowledge, part Pretty Woman, part Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, and all entertaining."^[12]

The review website the14amazons.com gave the film 2.5 out of 5 stars, calling it "forgettable". The review concludes, "Basically, LOVE FOR ALL SEASONS is a reasonably well made but ultimately disposable piece of fluff, made to satisfy conservative investors and a certain section of the audience that can still be made to go to see a local production if the right stars are in it. It's not a bad film, but it adds little to the world of cinema that hasn't been seen too many times before. Not recommended, not un-recommended. See it if you feel like it!"^[13]

• Love for All Seasons at IMDb
• Love for All Seasons at Hong Kong Movie Database
• Love for All Seasons at Rotten Tomatoes