In 1853, Demetrius Ellis Young sold two acres of land to William H. Hughes, which was claimed to be the highest point between Weldon, North Carolina and Raleigh, North Carolina.[4] This land had previously been set aside for an all-male educational academy that had been operating for the last decade. It would instead be used as the site of the Hughes house, a Greek Revival style dwelling[6] which was completed in 1855. In the years following the American Civil War, Hughes experienced a number of financial problems and became unable to continue repayment of his debt for the land. An extended court battle ensued between the Hughes and Young families and ultimately the land was returned to the Youngs in 1883. The heir to the land, Colonel Ike J. Young, began working on plans for a significant redesign and rebuilding of the Hughes house.[4]
It is widely speculated that well-known Philadelphia-based architect Samuel Sloan was commissioned to dramatically redesign the Hughes house. Sloan was working in North Carolina on another prominent structures in 1883, including the North Carolina Executive Mansion in Raleigh. Distinct similarities between the completed Mistletoe Villa and the Executive mansion, down to the final color scheme, are often cited by historians as evidence of Sloan's involvement in the design.[2] Unfortunately Sloan died in Raleigh in 1884, before either project was completed.[7] As construction was nearing completion in 1885, Colonel Young made a trip to New York City in search of furnishings for the new home where suffered a stroke and died, never having the opportunity to claim the house as a home.[4]
The newly over-built house extends beyond the original stone foundation of the Hughes house, which is still visible. A number of indoor elements, including floor boards, doors, lock hardware, mantels and others items were preserved and repurposed in the house. The completed house is an example of Queen Anne Style Victorian architecture and features multi-faceted detail woodwork.[8] The house was originally lighted by carbide light fixtures which were fueled by gas generated on the property in a small brick building and piped into the house. Although unusual for the era, the house was equipped with indoor plumbing which was supplied and pressurized by a large reservoir in the attic which functioned similarly to a simple water tower. The house also contained other innovative elements for the time including a "speak tube" which would allow people in the dining room to communicate with servants in the kitchen on the floor below.[5] A button was also integrated into the floor of the dining room which, when pressed, would alert servants downstairs that assistance was desired upstairs.[3]
During World War II, a 30-foot square iron widow's walk on the roof was donated to the U.S. Government, which was looking for scrap metal from civilians to aide in the war effort.[3] During that same period, trains transporting U.S. troops would pass the house and deliver German prisoners of war to a factory next door to work. Children growing up in the house described having conversations with German prisoners with the assistance of a translator as well as playing games of catch with them.[9]
It is unknown exactly when the house was given its distinctive name but it has been attributed to "all the mistletoe that just drooled from the trees."[4]
