Nothing Very Important and Other Stories

A student club called the Hyde Park Club produced a play based on the book in November 1983.^[7] Dennis Clark and Harlow Clark led the group.^[6] Petsco was pleased with the adaptation, calling it "remarkably fine."^[8] BYU Student newspaper The Daily Universe refused to advertise for the play; they explained to student director David Cameron that administrators didn't want the production to appear that it had the university's endorsement.^[9] The play was also performed at the Orem Public Library. Writing to the editor at The Daily Herald, A. J. Nielson believed that the production had "universal appeal" and that the acting in the production was good.^[10]

Dallin H. Oaks, then-president of BYU ^{[clarification needed]}, wrote a letter to Ezra Taft Benson, then the President of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles (LDS Church). The letter is quoted in Bergera's and Priddis's Brigham Young University: A House of Faith. In it, Oaks said that Nothing Very Important "does not strengthen [Petsco's] efforts for employment at BYU".^[11] Petsco's adjunct contract was not renewed in 1983. Petsco's health declined and he stopped writing fiction after this time.^[6]

Lavina Fielding Anderson described it as part of a movement in the 1960s and 1970s where Mormon authors writing literary fiction "occupied an uncomfortable no-man's land."^[3] The collection of linked stories won the 1979 Association for Mormon Letters award for short fiction. The award citation stated that it marked a milestone in Mormon literature, as "an important modern fictional work by and about a Latter-day Saint reared outside of the Wasatch-front cultural tradition."^[12][13] The stories were based on events from Petsco's life as a missionary in Southern California.^[1]

Reviews at the time acknowledged the book's limitations while praising its unique voice. Writing for the Association for Mormon Letters newsletter, Elouise Bell gave the book a favorable review. "It is when the realism of the human animal encounters the idealism of the Mormon soul that the author's best stories result." She wrote that while Petsco's writing was "smooth, professional, and highly readable" that he had not yet mastered the genre of the self-contained short story.^[14] At Sunstone, Elizabeth Shaw wrote that the book did not explore moral dilemmas as thoroughly as other missionary fiction. However, Shaw wrote that "the mood that emerges from Petsco's understated, almost off-hand prose allows me to face--without guilt--the cultural vagaries I assume by virtue of my membership in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. And that's a major accomplishment."^[15] She summarized the work as "quick and clear and complex and renewing".^[15] Michael Olsen at The Payson Chronicle wrote that the book was "one of the most truthful but sometimes painfully objective pictures of Mormonism yet to come from the point of view of a true believer."^[1]

In a 2002 review for the AML blog, William Morris wrote that the stories seemed innocent, and deserve readers who "will interact intensely with the text, yet at the end, not draw any conclusions or insist on interpretation".^[16]

In his essay "The Dawning of a Brighter Day: Mormon Literature after 150 Years", Eugene England mentioned Nothing Very Important in connection with emerging good books in Mormon literature.^[17] In his introduction to Bright Angels and Familiars, England said that Nothing Very Important was, like Bread and Milk (1979) and Elders and Sisters (1977), a series of stories connected by a longer narrative.^[18] Bruce Jorgensen mentioned Nothing Very Important as "the first entirely non-Utah-Idaho Mormon fiction" in the Encyclopedia of Mormonism.^[19] Marilyn Brown referred to Bela Petsco as one of the best Mormon short story writers and noted his absence in the anthology Greening Wheat.^[20] In a summary of local fiction for The Daily Herald, Richard Cracroft mentioned Nothing Very Important along with Cory Davidson as recent "regional best-sellers in a literary genre" about missionary life.^[21] Cracroft also mentioned Petsco's book in a 1981 Ensign article in a section on current Mormon fiction, comparing it to Winesburg, Ohio by Sherwood Anderson.^[22]