Pawn Shop (album)

Both members of the duo (John and T.J. Osborne) co-wrote nearly every song on the album, except "Heart Shaped Locket", on which only TJ was a co-writer. Jay Joyce produced the album except for "Rum" and "Heart Shaped Locket", which the duo produced with Brad Hill.^[7] Both "Rum" and "Stay a Little Longer" previously appeared on their self-titled EP,^[8] although the latter was re-recorded. "Rum" was originally issued as a single off the EP in 2014, followed by the re-recording of "Stay a Little Longer" as the lead single from Pawn Shop. "21 Summer" and "It Ain't My Fault" were the album's second and third singles.

Rating it 4 out of 5 stars, Allmusic critic Stephen Thomas Erlewine felt that the album's sound combined modern and traditional country influences, staying that "Sanded and varnished though they may be, the pair feel fresh, their chemistry easy and natural, so they pull off their spiffy retroact with style."^[9] Jeffrey B. Remz of Country Standard Time made note of Southern rock and outlaw country influences in the sound, while also comparing T.J.'s voice to that of Trace Adkins. His review highlighted the lyrics to "It Ain't My Fault" and the instrumentation of "Stay a Little Longer", concluding that there were "no weak songs".^[10] Markos Papadatos of Digital Journal rated it "A−", calling it "a well-crafted project from start to finish" and praising the songwriting and arrangement of the singles in particular.^[11]

The album debuted at No. 3 on the Top Country Albums album, and No. 17 on the Billboard 200, selling 21,000 copies in its first week.^[12] It sold a further 6,100 copies in its second week.^[13] The album was certified Gold on November 16, 2017.^[14] It has sold 237,100 copies in the US as of October 2019.^[15]

From Pawn Shop liner notes.^[7]

Brothers Osborne

• John Osborne – autoharp, acoustic guitar, baritone guitar, electric guitars, 12-string guitar, banjo, mandolin, pedal steel guitar, bass guitar, percussion, backing vocals
• T.J. Osborne – lead vocals, acoustic guitar, percussion

Additional Musicians

• Dave Cohen – acoustic piano, Hammond B3 organ
• Ian Fitchuk – Wurlitzer electric piano, Hammond B3 organ, percussion
• Jay Joyce – acoustic piano, Hammond B3 organ, guitars, percussion
• Jon Green – acoustic guitar
• Lee Holland – acoustic guitar, percussion
• Josh Matheny – lap steel guitar
• Rich Brinsfield – bass guitar, upright bass
• Rachel Loy – bass guitar
• Pete Sternberg – bass guitar, bass pedals
• Adam Box – drums, percussion
• Lee Ann Womack – backing vocals (6)
• Lucie Silvas – backing vocals (11)

Group vocals on "21 Summer"

• John Osborne, Natalie Osborne, T.J. Osborne, Lucie Silvas and Pete Sternberg