Perfect Shirl

Perfect Shirl did not race at age two, then failed to win in her first three races in 2010 at age three. She finally won for the first time in a maiden special weight race on the turf at Woodbine on June 13. She then followed up with a win on the Woodbine's Polytrack artificial dirt surface in an allowance race on July 11.^[1] On July 28, she was shipped to Saratoga racetrack for the Grade II Lake George Stakes on the turf, where she went off at odds of 9-1. Racing in the middle of the pack down the backstretch, Perfect Shirl started making up ground around the far turn and then moved to the lead as they neared the finish line. "When I asked her, she responded very well," said jockey John Velazquez. "The only thing the assistant told me was not to be on the lead; very simple instructions!"^[4]

Perfect Shirl then finished third in the Del Mar Oaks on August 21 and eighth in the Queen Elizabeth II Challenge Cup Stakes on October 16 at Keeneland. Atfield then gave the filly a long layoff, returning on April 16, 2011 in an allowance race at Woodbine. Perfect Shirl finished fourth and then lost her next five races as well.^[1] However, her performance in the Canadian Stakes was promising: she circled the field and closed rapidly to lose by only half-a-length.^[5]

Despite her lengthy losing streak, Attfield decided to enter the filly in the Breeders' Cup Filly and Mare Turf, held that year at Churchill Downs on November 4. Ridden again by Velazquez, she was a 27-1 longshot in a quality field featuring Stacelita and several highly regarded horses from Europe. The course was wet, which concerned Attfield, but the going was rated as good. Perfect Shirl raced behind the leaders for the first mile, then moved to the center of the racetrack and accelerated past the leaders to win by three-quarters of a length. It was the first Breeders' Cup win for both Attfield and Fipke.^[6] "I had my doubts about running her," said Attfield. "I was very concerned because she's never been able to handle a soft course. Once I saw how she was moving down the backside, I could see she was moving beautifully and I became very excited."^[7]

Perfect Shirl made one last start on February 25, 2012 in The Very One Stakes at Gulfstream Park. She finished eighth and was retired.^[1] Her first foal, More Perfect by More than Ready, was foaled in 2014.^[8]