Pictures (Katie Melua album)

Pictures, Melua's third album, was initially announced to be, at least temporarily, the last of her albums in collaboration with Mike Batt as lead writer and producer.^[1] The album features contributions from several songwriters, including Melua's friend Molly McQueen, the former frontwoman of The Faders, who co-wrote "Perfect Circle". Melua also collaborated with Andrea McEwan, who wrote the lyrics for "What I Miss About You" and "Dirty Dice".^[2] The album includes a cover version of "In My Secret Life", originally written by Leonard Cohen and Sharon Robinson. Discussing the song, Melua stated that it resonated with her because it explores the contrast between people's ideals and the realities of everyday life, noting that "we all have great ideals but in reality we end up conforming, following everyone else."^[3]

More information Review scores, Source ...

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[4]
Digital Spy	[5]
The Guardian	[6]
laut.de	[7]
Q	[8]
Virgin Media	[8]

Close

Pictures received generally positive reviews from critics. In a positive review for BBC Music, Lizzie Ennever praised Melua's voice, subtle songwriting, and varied musical influences. Although she found some songs "bland and forgettable" and considered lead single "If You Were a Sailboat" a safe choice, Ennever concluded that she was "erring on the side of good" rather than "undecided" regarding the album.^[9] Nick Levine of Digital Spy was similarly positive, arguing that Melua's self-written songs were "more vital, more interesting and more affecting" than those written by Mike Batt, and citing "Perfect Circle", "Spellbound", and "What I Miss About You" as highlights. While he criticized several of Batt's contributions as overly whimsical and described "Ghost Town" as the album's "only real stinker", Levine felt that Pictures benefited from Melua's growing artistic independence.^[5]

Other reviews were more mixed. Writing for The Guardian, Betty Clarke praised Melua's gentle, blues-influenced vocals and suggested that self-written tracks such as "Spellbound" demonstrated artistic growth, but criticized Batt's lyrics as "shocking" and often detrimental to the songs. She concluded that Melua was beginning to "rescu[e] her career" by emerging from Batt's creative influence.^[6] In a largely negative review for Virgin Media, Tony Bartholomew criticized Batt's songwriting as "twee and inoffensive" and his lyrics as "truly dreadful". Nevertheless, he praised Melua's own compositions, including "What I Miss About You", "Dirty Dice", and "Perfect Circle", as evidence that she had "outgrown her mentor", despite awarding the album just one star out of five.^[8]

Pictures achieved significant commercial success across Europe following its release. The album reached number one in both the Netherlands and Switzerland,^[10][11] while also peaking at number two in Austria,^[12] Belgium's Wallonian region,^[13] Denmark,^[14] Germany,^[15] Norway,^[16] and the United Kingdom,^[17] where it opened with 53,878 copies sold in its first week.^[18] In Belgium's Flemish region, the album reached number ten,^[19] and it also attained top-five positions in France,^[20] Poland,^[21] Portugal,^[22] Scotland,^[23] and on the UK Independent Albums Chart, where it topped the chart.^[24] Outside Europe, Pictures reached number 63 on the Australian Albums Chart,^[25] number 27 in New Zealand,^[26] and number 11 on the US Heatseekers charts.^[27] Additional top-twenty placements were recorded in Finland, Italy, and Sweden.^[28][29][30]

The album's strongest market was the Netherlands, where it became the best-performing album of 2007 on the Dutch Albums Chart and later ranked number 27 on the Dutch decade-end albums chart for the 2000s.^[31] It also appeared on several year-end charts across Europe, including number 9 in Switzerland,^[32] and number 49 on the UK Albums year-end chart in 2007.^[33] The album continued to perform strongly into 2008, appearing on year-end charts in Belgium, Germany, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom.^[34] Pictures also received numerous sales certifications across Europe and beyond. It was certified Gold in Austria,^[35] Belgium,^[36] Portugal,^[37] and Sweden;^[38] Platinum in Denmark,^[39] France,^[40] Germany,^[41] the Netherlands,^[42] New Zealand,^[43] and the United Kingdom;^[44] and double Platinum in Switzerland.^[45] Collectively, these certifications reflected strong sales throughout its international markets. In recognition of its continental success, Pictures was awarded Platinum certification by the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) for shipments exceeding one million units across Europe.^[46]