After his playing days, Lawrence transitioned into coaching, taking the helm of Life University's men's rugby team. Under his leadership, the program achieved significant success, winning various titles in the D1A National Championship.[7]
Lawrence's tenure at Life University not only brought accolades to the institution but also helped in nurturing and developing talent (players & coaches) that would go on to represent the USA on international stages.
In 2011, Lawrence coached the United States U20 national team at the 2011 and 2012 Junior World Rugby Trophy, leading the team to victory in the 2012 tournament.[8]
In May 2017, Lawrence left Life University and returned to USA Rugby, becoming defence coach of the national team.[9][10] By July, he had helped secure qualification for the 2019 Rugby World Cup and in 2018, he was part of the coaching team that saw the United States retain the Americas Rugby Championship title.
Along side his duties as the national defence coach, he also became head coach of the USA Selects for the 2017 and 2018 World Rugby Americas Pacific Challenge.
His coaching journey continued in 2019, becoming the inaugural head coach of Rugby ATL in the Major League Rugby competition ahead of the 2020 season. However, the season was cut short due to the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2021, Rugby ATL topped the Eastern Conference before going onto finish as runners-up to LA Giltinis in final.[11]
In January 2022, Lawrence unexpectedly resigned from his position at Rugby ATL two weeks short of the start of the 2022 season.[12] Whilst the reason for stepping down were not explained, Lawrence later rejoined the national team set-up, taking back up the position of defence coach.[13]
After filing to qualify for the 2023 Rugby World Cup, the then head coach Gary Gold resigned as head coach, prompting USA Rugby to appoint Lawrence as interim Head Coach for 2023.[14]
Lawrence's first match in charge was a 31–17 victory over Romania as part of The Oaks preparations for the 2023 Rugby World Cup, before going onto lose to Georgia and Portugal. More notably, he led his side to a 24–21 victory over French Top 14 side Toulouse,[15] before going onto secure the La Vila International Rugby Cup in November with wins over Spain and Brazil.
In January 2024, Scott Lawrence was officially appointed Head Coach of the USA Men’s Eagles and General Manager of the USA Men’s XVs programs.[16]
During the 2024 season, Lawrence led his side to fourth place in the 2024 World Rugby Pacific Nations Cup, and an unbeaten autumn European tour for the first time since 2013; with wins over Portugal, Tonga (their first over the nation since 1999), and Spain.