Shipwreck (album)

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[13]
Chicago Tribune	[14]
MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide	[7]
The Province	[4]

Rolling Stone stated: "Its music gorgeous, its lyrics strange, confessional and sometimes oddly comic, Shipwreck is a stunning album—a furious attempt to fashion something glorious."^[15] Trouser Press wrote that "Connelly's pronounced vocal resemblance to Bowie remains disarming throughout Shipwreck's eleven fascinating chapters, but as long as the real thing shows no inclination of creating music this affecting and accessible, Connelly might as well make the most of it."^[16] The Baltimore Sun deemed Shipwreck an "amiably upbeat album recalls the arty appeal of late-'70s David Bowie."^[17]

The Chicago Tribune called the album "a masterful blend of creepy atmospherics, the odd noise, visceral guitars-and-drums interplay and folkish melodies-delivered in Connelly's evocative, brogue-tinged tenor."^[14] The St. Louis Post-Dispatch thought that Shipwreck "ditches the industrial shtick for a near art/rock approach."^[18] The Los Angeles Times opined that, "even among the obvious Bowie-isms, there was enough sense of personal vision to indicate that Connelly can transcend the reference and stake out territory distinctly his own."^[19]

AllMusic wrote that "most of the songs have a sharp acoustic/electric guitar kick and at once rough and carefully produced feel to them."^[13] MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide deemed Shipwreck "one of the great, overlooked albums of the decade."^[7]