Simeon Cottle

In his freshman year, Cottle averaged 3.9 points per game, being a part of a team that made the 2023 NCAA tournament, where he contributed 7 points in Kennesaw State's loss in the Round of 64 against Xavier.^[12]

Cottle's performance greatly improved in his sophomore year.^[13] On December 2, Cottle had a then-career-high 27 points in a win against Georgia State.^[14] The following game, Cottle made a game-winning three point buzzer beater in a win against UNC Asheville.^[12] Cottle had his then ASUN career-high in points on January 18, scoring 25 in a loss against North Florida.^[15] In what would be Kennesaw State's last game of the season, Cottle had a season-high in points, scoring 29 in a loss in the first round of the 2024 ASUN tournament against Jacksonville.^[16]

On December 29, 2024, Cottle set a new career-high in points, scoring 32 in a win against Brewton–Parker.^[17] Cottle set a then-career-high in points in a conference game on February 6, scoring 30 in a win against Western Kentucky.^[18] Cottle tied his career-high in points in the quarterfinal round of the 2025 Conference USA tournament, scoring 32 again against New Mexico State, helping Kennesaw State achieve their first Conference USA tournament win in program history.^[19] Following the season, Cottle was named to the second-team All-CUSA men's basketball team.^[20]

Before his senior season, Cottle was selected as the preseason Conference USA Player of the Year.^[20] On November 26, Cottle set a new career-high in points, scoring 33 in an overtime win against Florida Gulf Coast.^[21] Following that performance, in addition to scoring 15 points against Oral Roberts and 25 points against Rice, Cottle was named both the Conference USA Player of the Week and one of five National Players of the Week by the U.S. Basketball Writers Association.^[22] On January 7, Cottle scored 25 points, along with notching 11 assists, registering his first double-double of his collegiate career in a win against Missouri State.^[23] The following game, Cottle scored 28 points and set the record for the most three-pointers by a Kennesaw State player in their career, in a win against Jacksonville State.^[24] For his efforts in both games, Cottle was again named Conference USA Player of the Week.^[23]

In January 2026, Cottle was one of many college basketball players to be named in a federal indictment involving sports betting and a point-shaving scheme.^[25] According to the indictment, Cottle was allegedly contacted by former NBA player Antonio Blakeney about participating in a sports betting conspiracy.^[26] Cottle is then accused of recruiting then-current Kennesaw State player Demond Robinson and another unnamed individual.^[27] Prior to a game against Queens on March 1, 2024, Cottle was supposedly texted by another alleged fixer, Jalen Smith, that he needed to FaceTime Cottle before the game, and that the latter would be in attendance at the game with money for Cottle, Robinson, and the unnamed third player.^[26] Cottle and the two other players were allegedly told to underperform to allow Queens to cover the first-half spread of –1.5.^[27] Queens outscored Kennesaw State 52 to 39 in the first half, with Cottle scoring 0 points in the first half compared to 13 in the second half.^[28] In the following days, Cottle was allegedly given his bribe payment by Smith on campus at Kennesaw State, totalling $40,000 in cash.^[27] Cottle and Smith were also accused of attempting to continue working together after the Queens game, with Cottle trying to recruit other Kennesaw State players and Smith offering to show them $200,000 to persuade them, but Cottle supposedly told Smith that no players were interested in the deal.^[26] Cottle is facing federal charges of bribery in sporting contests, aiding and abetting, and conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and also has been suspended indefinitely from the Kennesaw State basketball team.^[25]