Skin (Peter Himmelman album)

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[12]
Chicago Tribune	[9]
The Encyclopedia of Popular Music	[13]
The Indianapolis Star	[10]
Knoxville News Sentinel	[14]
MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide	[15]
Windsor Star	C[16]

The Washington Post deemed the album "a legitimate rock opera."^[17] The New York Times wrote that it "moves from hymns to guitar-strumming waltzes to up-tempo, neo-1960's rock."^[18] The Knoxville News Sentinel called Skin "trite," writing that the album "lacks the character motivation and simple details that should move the story along, which is particularly damning considering Himmelman seems to have sleighted the music on behalf of the lyrics."^[14]

The Chicago Tribune praised the "solid pop-rock-folk tunesmithy" of Himmelman.^[9] The Daily Press stated: "Filled with memorable songs, such as the gripping rockers 'Easy to Be Broken' and '11 Months in the Bath of Dirty Spirits', the stark ballad 'Nowhere Else to Go' and the elegant record-ending track 'Been Set Free', Skin is both musically and lyrically ambitious."^[11] Newsday labeled it "a ponderously flimsy concept work about corruption, death, rebirth and redemption in which the alternation of loud theatricality and quiet keyboard-violin delicacy sounded like a baseball game between Pink Floyd and Meat Loaf."^[19]

AllMusic wrote that "the occasional heavy-handedness and meandering subplots hardly mar this impressive work."^[12]