Sonia first appears in Season 4, Episode 6 'Divide and Conquer', having been remanded at Wentworth pending trial for the murder of her friend, Helen Masters. The entire evidence against Sonia is circumstantial and in an attempt to secure a conviction, Detective Don Kaplan approaches Liz Birdsworth (Celia Ireland) offers her immediate parole in exchange for obtaining a confession from Sonia. Initially reluctant, Liz is desperate to be free from prison and agrees. Throughout the rest of Season 4, Liz repeatedly attempts to get Sonia to talk about Helen's murder but Sonia remains aloof and adamant of her innocence. Liz considers retracting her offer to assist the police but becomes certain of Sonia's guilt when, in the season finale, she delivers a cryptic message, when cutting Maxine Conway's hair, that she may have had something to do with the murder, referring to cutting hair as taking a crown away (Helen Masters had had her hair cut off shortly after her murder).
In Season 5, Sonia remains aloof. Don Kaplan grows impatient and advises Liz to lie under oath in court. Despite being warned off by Doreen Anderson (Shareena Clanton), Liz agrees. However, when giving evidence in court, Sonia's defence team produce evidence that ultimately prove that Liz is lying and Sonia is cleared of all charges. When relaxing at home that evening, Sonia is visited by Don, thus revealing that he had been conspiring with her all along. Flashbacks reveal that Sonia had in fact murdered Helen, who had attempted to blackmail her over the mysterious death of her husband. Sonia then turned to Don for assistance in concealing Helen's body. Unable to protect Sonia from being charged, he informs her the only way to free her is to get her cleared of all charges when it came to court. They choose Liz as their patsy. Don then asks Sonia what really happened to Geoffrey Stevens. Initially reluctant to talk about it, Sonia agrees to show him where she hid his body. However she secretly plans to murder him. Don suspects this and overpowers her, fleeing abroad, but not before anonymously reporting Sonia to the police. She is arrested and charged with her husband's murder.