The song received generally positive reviews. Angel Diaz of Billboard ranked it as the best song from Don't Be Dumb.[5] Likewise, Dimas Sanfiorenzo of Complex considered the run from "Playa" to "Stop Snitching" among the album's "best material".[6] Alexander Cole of HotNewHipHop wrote of the song, "One of those fun songs is the track 'Stop Snitching,' which features the likes of Sauce Walka. Overall, it is a unique song, especially when you consider what Sauce Walka typically raps on. Having said that, there is some solid rapping here, and we're fans of the song so far."[7] Paste's Casey Epstein-Gross and Variety's Peter A. Berry both regarded the song's diss to be entertaining;[3][4] Berry stated "Rocky distills what sounds like years' worth of bitterness toward cooperators who made rapper RICO charges possible."[4] Music critics also praised Sauce Walka's performance; Pitchfork's Paul A. Thompson commented "The flaccidity of 'Stole Ya Flow' is mitigated somewhat by Rocky's inclusion of a truly show-stopping verse from Sauce Walka on 'Stop Snitching'".[8] In an album review, Kyann-Sian Williams of NME wrote "Elsewhere, Rocky occasionally gets eclipsed. Sauce Walka walks him down on 'Stop Snitching', seizing the beat's blaring horns with Southern twang and precision."[1]