@Greglocock: I'll respond with a question: why are we including the Benz Velo?
- If we want a list of just strict time trials, I'm not aware of any surviving Velo being raced up to it's top speed under an independent two-way road test. (Correct me if I'm wrong, and if so, we should cite that source!)
- It also does not exceed 124mph for it's claimed speed, (which seems to be a speed selected because it's about the speed Autoweek's test of the XK120 managed to exceed).
- And it's obviously not post-1945.
So presumably we are including it to show the history and development of faster and faster automobiles...and yet, we then choose to omit all automobiles until 1945.
So the inclusion of the Velo is just kind of, arbitrary and doesn't contribute anything to this list as it stands realistically.
(the original discussion can be found back in 2012 at Talk:List of production car speed records/Archive 2#Early production cars).
I'll make two suggestions: (1) Remove the Velo, or, (2) Remove the no-pre-1945 & under 124mph requirement.
I think we have maybe slept on a suggestion made by @NealeFamily: "maybe with a split table". You can reconcile the fact that we cannot hold early cars to a quite as strict standard as later ones with regards to speed claims then, and then it'd let the Velo sit in with other cars from it's era to show the development of cars in the early days.
~2026-41111-87 (talk) 14:06, 30 July 2026 (UTC)
- I suggest you read the archives. I agree the Velo doesn't really fit the criteria, perhaps we need a note to that effect. The problem is that until comparatively recently establishing the top speed was often done in dubious circumstances and frequently with modified cars - a problem we still face occasionally. Please read the archives and see how we ended up where we are. Greglocock (talk) 00:21, 31 July 2026 (UTC)
- I did read the archives, read my comment!
- I would favour a split table set up and including pre-1945 cars in their own table personally (and I'd suggest we look at the page Longevity claims as a plausible starting point which could be followed), however if not that then I suggest we remove the Velo entirely as there's no real point for including it then. ~2026-41111-87 (talk) 22:07, 31 July 2026 (UTC)