A September 2, 1945 review in the Louisville Courier Journal described the premise of the show, and concluded, "If this is the television programming the big brains are giving forth, cancel my order for a set, will you please?"[2]
The October 20, 1945 edition of Billboard magazine gave the series a mixed review, saying of the series "Tele-truth, despite its corny name, is the first video quiz this department has seen so far which was 100 per cent visual and perhaps 85 per cent entertaining", but also said that "Teletruth could be improved considerably if a few things were done to it."[3]
A later review in Billboard reported that a magician's hands were not fast enough, so that sometimes "it was obvious just what he was doing."[4] The review also found fault with the camera work and noted that "questions must still be within the kid scope and plenty of them weren't this evening."[4]
