The Adding Machine (film)

The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "This adaptation of Elmer Rice's 1923 play keeps fairly closely to the original text apart from two or three irrelevant additions. But though pleasant enough to watch, the film manages to miss most of the essential points of the play, which requires a much more stylised approach than the one Epstein has adopted. ... Though it is difficult to believe in Billie Whitelaw as a middleaged spinster who spends her time wondering what 'them kisses in the movies' are like, all five leading characters are well played, and the film is a charming one which its director has reportedly described as a 'labour of love'. But this love is also its weakness: a more compelling film could have been made from Rice's play if the theme, a sort of nightmare vision of mechanised robot man, had been treated less naturalistically and with far more satirical bite and savagery."^[3]

Roger Greenspun wrote in the New York Times: "Virtually everything in this movie version is a bad idea poorly realized. Epstein's direction is straight pre-New Wave academic, with absolutely regular cross-cutting punctuated by occasional lyrical montage to indicate imagination. He has softened the play a bit, added a dumb discourse on violence, added a needless prison scene for Phyllis Diller, and moved the Elysian Fields to an amusement park. For frumpy Daisy Devore, Zero's long-lost office romance, he has miscast Billie Whitelaw, who would still look ravishing if she dressed in cast iron and took ugly pills for a year. Indeed, each member of the distinguished cast is in his own way unsuitable."^[4]

Leslie Halliwell said: "Elmer Rice's satirical fantasy of the twenties is here robbed of its expressionist staging and presented naturalistically, a fatal error from which the film never for one moment recovers."^[5]

• The Adding Machine at IMDb