The Best of Raymond Z. Gallun

James McGlothlin on blackgate.com writes that he "really, really struggled reading" the book due to Gullun's "stiff" writing style, "wooden" characterizations, and typically "cold-hearted" protagonists, as well as his "often ... breaking the 'Show, Don't Tell' rule of good writing." He notes that "dispassionate, resourceful scientists — human or alien — are usually the heroes of Gallun's stories. Or better, one might say Science (with a capital 'S' is the real hero." He finds "one good quality that clearly comes across" in the author's fascination "with natural events or scientific phenomena that seemingly could not take place within the bounds of known science" that he "greatly enjoyed [demonstrating] might be plausibly and scientifically viable" in "stories [that] usually attempted to encourage wonder at what science might be capable of explaining." McGlothlin finds this "a novel aesthetic and perhaps educational goal." Nonetheless, he feels Gallun "is probably best seen as an historical example of a bygone day," who "might still occasionally inspire scientific awe in some, but ... is more likely to leave one fairly cold."^[2]

"Seeds of the Dusk" was a preliminary nominee for the 1939 Retro Hugo Award for Best Novelette in 2014.^[1]