The Black Abbot (1934 film)

Kine Weekly wrote: "Unpretentious crime drama, conventional spot 'the-culprit' stuff, not particularly strong in dramatic, values, but sufficiently mystifying in its development to hold, the interest and enable the ending to occasion surprise. ... John Stuart is quite good as the hero; Judy Kelly is an attractive heroine, Richard Cooper is effective in a silly ass role, and the others are satisfactory. ... The story, a mechanical one, is a trifle involved, but its complexities nevertheless pave the way to new exciting situations which culminate with the customary thrill."^[4]

Picturegoer wrote: "John Stuart does well and Judy Kelly makes an attractive heroine in a conventional machine-made 'spot the criminal' story, which is weak dramatically and lacking in imaginative treatment. There is a certain amount of surprise element."^[5]

The Daily Film Renter wrote: "Film moves sluggishly, owing to overmuch dialogue, and climax lacks suspense values. Richard Cooper and Judy Kelly give best performances with material available. ... There is nothing strikingly original about this story, which follows familiar paths, in that suspicion is diverted into several unlikely channels before the denouement. Direction is on the slow side, while the unmasking lacks dramatic punch. Judy Kelly, as Sylvia, has little to do, although she manages to do that little well, Richard Cooper wanders in and out the plot as an asinine peer, a role that is right up his alley."^[6]

• The Black Abbot at IMDb