The Changeling Sea

Publishers Weekly writes "[b]eautifully sustained metaphors and an even tone make this fantasy, like McKillip's The Forgotten Beasts of Eld, a pleasure to read. Further, McKillip's deft characterization and smooth, tender resolution result in a memorable, often poignant novel."^[2]

Susan L. Rogers in School Library Journal calls the book "[a]n enchanting fantasy that is tinged with realism and romance."^[3]

Ann F. Howey, in an in-depth article in Journal of the Fantastic Arts, notes that "The Changeling Sea is not the only one of McKillip's texts to employ feminist strategies, but it is significant that it does to for a younger audience." She feels "McKillip's novel empowers its female protagonist" and "suggests to its young readers (and reminds its not-so-young readers) that regardless of gender or class they have heroic potential, and the power to change themselves and possibly their world."^[4]

Matthew David Surridge at Blackgate.com deems the novel "excellent," judging it "precisely in the way it evokes the feel of a folktale, the feel of myth mixed with the matter of common life, that the book shines." He praises "the feel of the book, which has one of the more distinct tones of any genre fantasy I've come across," and notes that the author "subtly establishes the sea in this book as a kind of mythic underworld. It’s the land of Tolkien’s Faërie. The otherworld. That place beyond the fields we know to which our protagonist must venture to set things right. The title of the novel is precisely correct: the sea is the place of changes, ... a place of story, and things shift there as they do in fable." He concludes: "Formally, the story has strong romance aspects, but it’s also a comedy of a very old kind: a comedy in which the world is set to rights. It’s a romance in the old sense. Just as we see the magic edge-on, so we see the story. As the book goes on we realise we’ve come in at the end, that the trouble that set everything in motion began a generation ago. There was something tragic in the past, as fathers and mothers made their mistakes; but this is a comedy-romance, so it is a story of young people undoing the snarl their elders made. And it is effective, touching and quietly powerful."^[5]

The book was also reviewed by Tom Whitmore in Locus no. 336, January 1989, and Baird Searles in Isaac Asimov's Science Fiction Magazine v. 14, no. 9, September 1990.^[1]

The novel was nominated for the 1990 Mythopoeic Fantasy Award, and placed eighteenth in the 1989 Locus Poll Award for Best Fantasy Novel.^[1]