The Man They Could Not Hang (1934 film)

A few days prior to the film's premiere, the New South Wales police requested a number of cuts be made to the film regarding its depiction of the police. This was done, even though the film was set in England.^[11][12] Everyones said "The latest action has dealt a further blow to the confidence of local producers, who are emphatic that the gamut of censorial deliberations their pictures have to run is severe to a point of injustice."^[13]

Longford was unable to attend the premiere due to illness.^[14] In Sydney is screened on a double bill with Cinesound Varieties.

The film was given a poor critical reception, the Sydney Morning Herald calling it:

Purely antiquarian. The very language of the characters is far-off and unreal... could have been directed in a more convincing way.. The one bright spot in the whole melancholy chronicle is the acting of Mr. Ron Roberts... Given better material, this young man could do some excellent work.^[15]

Everyones summarised it as "A poor effort, prejudicial to the advancement of Australian production."^[16] A more detailed review stated it was unlikely to repeat the success of the silent versions:

As a production it is a retrogres-sive step in Australian effort. The old story of John Lee... has been amplified with a smuggling plot and much confusing mystery that leads nowhere and only serves to slow down the action. In dress and settings an effort has been made to preserve the English atmosphere; and if these results look amateurish they are highly professional by comparison with the acting and dialogue... The one possible exception is Ronald Roberts... If Australian production is to establish itself firmly with Australian picture-goers, it never can be by virtue of such offerings.^[17]

The critic from The Argus said that the film was:

Closer to the far-fetched melodrama of The Streets of London than to the realism of the better films of to-day. The story... doubtless contains good dramatic material, but Invicta Films, an Australian company, have so disguised it that it appears sillier than the creations of the hack scenario writer's fancy. The complicated story has been unwound in a rambling, disjointed fashion, and the dialogue is so childishly stiff and melodramatic that even the most docile audience is fidgeting and giggling before the end. The cast is full of those stage types that went out with the appearance of Pinero – the red-eyed village maiden, who murmurs "Justice will prevail", the moustached French villain, who cannot speak without leering, smirking and kissing his finger-tips, and the stalwart British policeman, who arrests the wrong man with the noble words, "Duty is duty." The spirit of the piece seems to have possessed the cast completely, but perhaps the stiffness of the acting is due to their ignorance of the difference between stage and screen technique.^[18]

The Courier Mail did say "the prison scenes are realistically done, and at times the tension is strong."^[19]

The Sydney Sun said "It would be too hard to say that the cast is not capable, because the dialogue is so stilted that a brilliant and most experienced group of players could make but little of It. That Ronald Roberts, as John Lee, comes through as a human being, proves that he is one of the most promising of Australia's younger actors."^[20]

The film obtained a small release in England where it also received bad reviews.^[21]

The movie performed solidly in country areas.^[22][23][24]

However, by the end of 1934 a trade paper reported it as having earned only £2,200 at the Australian box office with the possibility of this going up to £3,000 ("although it's doubtful"^[2]) and the sale to England giving it a chance to recoup the budget. It is unclear whether this happened.

In February 1935 Everyones observed a cinema in Perth reported the film "is once more demanding patronage... Well, well, there are some pictures that will never die."^[25] The film also reportedly did "big business" in Newcastle.^[26] BEF^[who?] said it did well in Melbourne and Brisbane.^[27]

Longford never made another feature as director.^[28]

• The Man They Could Not Hang at IMDb
• The Man They Could Not Hang at National Film and Sound Archive
• The Man They Could Not Hang at AustLit
• The Man They Could Not Hang at Oz Movies