The Milwaukee Road: Its First Hundred Years

Contemporary reviewers expressed mixed reactions to the book. Charles W. Paape of the Carnegie Institute of Technology criticized Derleth for writing an apologia for the Milwaukee Road and focusing too heavily on the company's administration.^[1] Irene Dorothy Neu at Cornell University echoed these criticisms, saying that Derleth's unfamiliarity with railroad history "handicapped" him and led him to rely on internal company sources, although she did praise the work as "absorbingly written."^[2] Writing in Minnesota History Rodney C. Loehr thought the book would "appeal to railroad fans" but criticized the relative lack of material concerning Minnesota. Loehr, like Paape and Neu, noted the "defensive" nature of the book but suggested that it might serve as a "needed antidote" to past attacks.^[3] The Milwaukee Road, for its part, published a favorable notice in the Milwaukee Magazine, its in-house publication.^[4]

Since publication Derleth's quotable prose and access to company records guaranteed the book a place in Milwaukee Road scholarship, and most works dealing with the railroad reference it. An annotated bibliography of Wisconsin history published in 1999 included the book and described it as "presented with a novelist's touch."^[5] Tom Murray's 2005 The Milwaukee Road quotes extensively from Derleth.^[6] Joseph P. Schwieterman's When the Railroad Leaves Town: American Communities in the Age of Rail Line Abandonment used Derleth as a principal reference for the entry on Harlowton, Montana, a former stop on the Milwaukee Road Pacific Extension.^[7] Craig Sanders incorporated it in his Limiteds, Locals, and Expresses in Indiana, 1838–1971.^[8] Matt Hiner, in a review for Railroad History on the occasion of University of Iowa Press' 2002 reprint, praised the book as "excellent, although now slightly dated" and stated that it was "neither apologist nor sycophantic."^[9]

The Creative Age Press published the book as part of its "The Railroads of America" series.^[1] The Milwaukee Road did not sponsor the book for its centennial though it did cooperate with Derleth, providing "data" and "photographs."^[10] The University of Iowa Press reprinted the book in 2002 with a foreword by H. Roger Grant.^[11]