The Palladium RPG Book 2: Old Ones

Palladium Books entered the fantasy role-playing game market in 1983 with Palladium Fantasy Role-Playing Game, and followed this immediately with several supplements, including Palladium RPG Book II: Old Ones, published in 1984. This 210-page perfect-bound softcover book was written by Kevin Siembieda, with cover art by Martin McKenna and interior art by Dave Carson, Scott Johnson, Michael Kucharski, Ramón Pérez, Kevin Siembieda, and Maryann Siembieda.^[2]

The first edition was reprinted in 1993 with new cover art by Kevin Siembieda. A second edition was published in 1996. ^[1]

In Issue 39 of Abyss, Jon Schuller liked the level of detail in the 1st edition of the book, noting "The background section of the book is pretty well done, with fairly detailed information ... useful maps and some very specific details for reference, making every setting potentially ready for play with little requirement from the gamemaster." However, Schuller found the whole thing unoriginal, writing, "The creatures are the traditional types found in AD&D and many other games. The adventure systems are predictable. The adventures have dungeon-type settings, and even the cities seem almost like dungeons." Schuller also pointed out that the Old Ones, the creatures for whom the book is titled, "are given less attention than they deserve and end up just being mega-monsters for the end of the adventure series." Schuller concluded that the book had good and bad aspects "and its value will depend on the needs of the individual gamer."^[3]

In Issue 11 of the British RPG magazine Arcane, Lucya Szachnowski reviewed the second edition, saying, "Old Ones is a must if you run the Palladium Fantasy RPG but don't own the first edition supplements, and it's versatile enough to use with other fantasy systems." However, Szachnowski pointed out "The main thing that lets the book down is its design. Although the illustrations are great, the maps are all rather bland. There is also no excuse for any second edition book having so many typos." Szachnowski concluded by giving the book a rating of 7 out of 10.^[4]

In the December 1997 edition of Dragon (Issue 242), Rick Swan called the second edition of Old Ones "a terrific sourcebook". He noted that "The level of detail is staggering; a typical city entry pinpoints more than 100 different locations (temples, granaries, tax offices) and provides dozens of adventure hooks. It’s a grim, vividly evoked world that feels alive; you can smell the sweat at the Gladiator School, taste the elderberry wine at Splash Tavern, feel a pickpocket's blade in your back at the Charm Emporium." He gave the book an above-average rating of 5 out of 6, with the comment "True, Old Ones owes a heavy debt to H. P. Lovecraft, but it’s still a dazzler."^[5]