The Secret Agent (2016 TV series)

Reviewing the first episode for The Guardian, Stephen Moss began by noting the bravery of adapting a book "which film critic Roger Ebert called 'perhaps the least filmable novel [Conrad] ever wrote'". Moss observed that, "In the book, the first secretary makes a brilliant, witty, scathing case for attacking science – indeed, attacking time itself, since Greenwich marks the prime meridian – but on TV we have to be shown it. The mystery, the enigma, the idea that an attack on the very idea of time is all that will shock the English middle class is lost. That, in essence, is the problem here: all the workings must be shown. Conrad's great, strange, tonally complex novel is reduced to a psychological thriller." He added, "You would never know from watching it that The Secret Agent is in some respects a funny book, certainly a deeply ironic one. Conrad based Verloc's attempt to bomb the observatory on a real incident in which a half-baked anarchist blew himself up, and his description of it in a later preface to the novel should be the starting point for any treatment. He called the ill-fated terrorist attack 'a blood-stained inanity of so fatuous a kind that it was impossible to fathom its origin by any reasonable or even unreasonable process of thought'".^[9]

In The Daily Telegraph, Gerard O'Donovan found that in the second episode,

There is such a dearth of decent human beings in The Secret Agent (BBC One) that it makes for a deeply uncomfortable viewing. Set at the precise point where political idealism and terrorism intersect, it features such cynicism at its core that, even 109 years since it was published, it feels utterly contemporary. Revolutionaries are portrayed as egoists and mad men. The concern for humanity loftily expressed by radicals and idealists is depicted as rarely extending beyond concern for themselves, let alone that of the ordinary man in the street.^[10]

However, he judged that the episode "had rather more bite than the first". O'Donovan added, "Marchant's skilful untangling of Conrad's over-complicated plot brought all this to the fore without sacrificing too much in the way of subtlety or surprise", before concluding: "It could have been the climax to a lesser drama. But with another full hour to go, the one thing that seems guaranteed by The Secret Agent is an even murkier – and perhaps still more affecting – trawl through a dark night of the human soul that, despite being dressed up in Victorian garb, feels wholly relevant to right now."^[10]

The third episode was not so well received. Many aspects of the original storyline had been changed, and the version was not entirely coherent. O'Donovan wrote that "the finale's relentless, drawn-out descent into bleakness quenched each spark as soon as it ignited. No one came out of this well. In the end you have to ask what was the point of making such a drama when it offered neither entertainment nor enlightenment on a subject so relevant to our times." He awarded it only two stars out of five.^[11]

• The Secret Agent at BBC Online
• The Secret Agent at IMDb
• BBC exploration of Conrad's novel and its themes