Under My Skin (Avril Lavigne album)

Having no plans of working with producers or professional writers,^[6] Lavigne wrote much of the album with Canadian singer-songwriter Chantal Kreviazuk, with whom she had developed a friendship in the summer of 2003. Kreviazuk, whose husband Raine Maida's band Our Lady Peace opened for Lavigne's concert in Europe, introduced herself at an after-party for the SARS benefit concerts held in Toronto in June 2003. The following day, Lavigne and Kreviazuk ate lunch together,^[7] during which Lavigne shared how she wanted the development of the album to be. They wrote songs for almost three weeks at Maida's warehouse in Toronto. Kreviazuk invited Lavigne to continue working in a Malibu, California house she shared with Maida, which contained a recording studio.^[8] Many of the tracks on the album were recorded in Malibu.

Kreviazuk suggested Maida produce songs for the album, an ability Lavigne did not possess. Maida produced five songs, including "Fall to Pieces", which he co-wrote with Lavigne.^[8] Lavigne also invited two other producers: Don Gilmore, who produced three songs, two of which were written by Lavigne and Kreviazuk,^[8] and Butch Walker who also produced three songs in three days.^[9] Lavigne also co-wrote one track, "Nobody's Home", with Ben Moody, formerly of Evanescence, and the rest with her guitarist Evan Taubenfeld.^[10][7]

On her website, Lavigne states that she had learned a lot since her first record, Let Go: "I was involved in every aspect of making this record. I'm very hands-on. I knew how I wanted the drums, the guitar tones, and the structures to be. I understand the whole process so much better this time because I've been through it. I'm really picky with my sound."^[11][7] Regarding the album's theme, Lavigne stated, "I've gone through so much, so that's what I talk about....Like boys, like dating or relationships".^[12]

Under My Skin is a departure from the upbeat pop-punk of Lavigne's debut studio album, Let Go, and most of her discography. The album has more melodic rock songs and a darker post-grunge,^[13][14][15] alternative rock,^[15][16] and nu metal sound,^{[17][18][19][20][21]} with elements of emo,^[22] gothic rock,^[23] grunge^[24] and pop metal.^[25] Matt Cibula of Music Critic compared the album to Dutch rock band the Gathering and Swedish heavy metal.^[26] Other reviewers noted similarities with Evanescence, Limp Bizkit and Nickelback.^[15][20]

Like its predecessor, Under My Skin is heralded as a pop-punk gem from the early 2000s, even if "He Wasn't" is the only song usually classified as such.^[2] Lyrically, it is also darker than Lavigne's other albums, bar Goodbye Lullaby, with more mature and personal topics to her, such as the passing of her grandfather during her first headlining tour, and her relationship with Sum 41’s Deryck Whibley.^[27] The album also anticipated the emotional intensity and theatrical aesthetics of emo pop, allowing bands, such as Fall Out Boy and My Chemical Romance, to see mainstream success later in the decade.^[3][4]

The lead single, "Don't Tell Me", is a grunge song with folk rock verses and a hard rock chorus, reminiscent of Alanis Morissette.^[28] The lyrics discuss how pressured girls can be, especially in high school, to have sex with men, often after a date. The second and most successful single, "My Happy Ending", is seen as a counter to "Sk8er Boi", from Let Go, depicting a relationship that ended badly after a happy beginning. "Nobody's Home" has a darker topic, as the song describes a young girl who ran away from home, living rough, and couldn’t return to her broken family.^[27]

"He Wasn’t" is a pop-punk song which was never released as a single in the U.S. While continuing the themes of relationships and disappointing exes, it is the most radio-friendly song on the album, foreshadowing the direction that Lavigne took on her next record, The Best Damn Thing (2007). The closing track, "Slipped Away", is written in honor of Lavigne's grandfather, who she never got to say goodbye to because of her tour.^[27]

Under My Skin was released on May 12, 2004, in Japan and later on May 25, 2004, in the United States and worldwide. Lavigne released four official singles from the album, and two promotional singles.

• "Don't Tell Me" was the first single from the album, written by Lavigne and Evan Taubenfeld and produced by Butch Walker. It earned Lavigne a nomination at the 2004 MTV VMAs, and charted at number 22 in the Billboard Hot 100, number five in the UK Singles Charts and the top 10 in Australia.
• "My Happy Ending" was the second single; it was written by Lavigne alongside its producer Butch Walker. The song returned Under My Skin to number one in Canada for several weeks, and to the top five in Germany, the UK, Australia, and other European countries. It was Lavigne's fourth number one single on the US Mainstream Top 40 and was her second platinum single since "Complicated" (2002). The song became a worldwide hit.
• "Nobody's Home" was the third single released from the album, written by Lavigne and former Evanescence member Ben Moody and produced by Don Gilmore. The song peaked lower in most countries than some of her previous singles.
• "He Wasn't" was the fourth single from the album, written by Lavigne and Chantal Kreviazuk and produced by Raine Maida. Despite charting in several countries, it was not a significant hit, failing to reach the top 20 in most markets. It was not released in the United States, where "Fall to Pieces" was released instead.
• "Fall to Pieces" was released in North America on April 18, 2005.

More information Aggregate scores, Source ...

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	65/100[34]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[35]
Blender	[33]
Entertainment Weekly	B[32]
The Guardian	[36]
PopMatters	[37]
Q
Rolling Stone	[38]
Slant Magazine	[39]
Yahoo! Music	6/10[40]

Close

According to Metacritic, Under My Skin received an average rating of 65, reflecting a positive reception from critics.^[41][42][34]. David Browne of Entertainment Weekly suggested that in the album, "Lavigne has become even more, well, complicated", noting she "sounds more burdened". Browne adds, "As contrived as the results can be, there's no denying the level of craft at work."^[32] Sal Cinquemani of Slant magazine noted that Lavigne's sound was now much heavier and darker and compared her to Amy Lee of Evanescence, as did Browne.^[32] Carly Carioli of Blender magazine also agreed, stating "she has deepened and darkened her sound without sacrificing her platinum-plated melodies".^[33] Kelefa Sanneh of Rolling Stone praised Lavigne's vocals, "blankness is what makes her best songs so irresistible. Whether it's a fit of faux punk or a maudlin ballad, she sings it all absolutely straight".^[38] Musically the album's sound is compared to "that of crunching punk guitars playing mighty power chords, all mixed with the same flawless elan that has characterized pop-punk ever since Green Day dropped Dookie" says Tim O'Neil of PopMatters.^[37] Andrew Strickland of Yahoo! Music agreed, "the girl can use those tiny lungs to great effect...she knows when to croon and when to yell". ^[40]

On a more mixed note, Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic wrote that the album is "a bit awkward, sometimes sounding tentative and unsure, sometimes clicking and surging on Avril's attitude and ambition." Erlewine compared Lavigne to Canadian singer-songwriter Alanis Morissette.^[35] Cinquemani cited Lavigne's lyrics as her "biggest weakness"^[39] and Strickland agreed, stating, "we have a maturing Ms Lavigne, distancing herself from the teen antics of her "Let Go" debut, but struggling to find any stories worth telling".^[40] Tim O'Neil of PopMatters stated "Lavigne's songwriting on the bulk of Under My Skin just seems rote" and goes on to call Under My Skin "a good, if slightly disappointing, follow-up".^[37] The Guardian's Alexis Petridis lambasted the album, calling it a "flesh-eating virus"^[43] and criticised the lyrics, stating "the music is so anodyne that you don't pay much attention to Lavigne's lyrics. This proves to be a small mercy".^[36] Under My Skin is included in an article about Petridis' worst reviewed albums of modern times.^[43]

Under My Skin debuted at number one on the US Billboard 200, selling 381,000 copies in its first week. This feat marked Lavigne's highest first-week sales of her career and also her first number-one album, It also topped the US Billboard Internet Albums chart, it spent 66 weeks on the US Billboard 200 chart.^[50][51] The album was certified double Platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) in November 2004; by January 2006 it was certified triple Platinum.^[52] The album was ranked at number 22 in the year-end chart of the Billboard 200 in 2004 and at number 68 in 2005. As of September 2015^[update], Under My Skin has sold 3.2 million copies in the US.^[53]

In Canada, Under My Skin debuted at number one on the Billboard Canadian Albums chart with sales of 63,000 copies, it spent 22 weeks on the chart.^[51] It was certified 5× Platinum in Canada with 500,000 copies sold,^[54] In the United Kingdom, the album debuted at number one on the UK Albums (OCC) with sales of 87,500 copies, it spent 37 weeks on the chart.^[55] It was certified 2× Platinum in the UK with sales of 600,000 copies sold.^[56] In Japan the album debuted at number one on the Japanese Albums (Oricon) chart with sales of 286,894 copies,^[57] and was certified Million in Japan with sales of 1 million copies sold making it the best selling album in the country by a female Canadian singer, and also number one in Australia, Spain, Mexico, Taiwan and Germany. In New Zealand the album debuted at number seven on the New Zealand Albums (RMNZ) and spent five months on the chart and was certified Gold in the country. On April 15, 2007, the album re-entered the UK Albums Chart at number 60. Worldwide, Under My Skin had sold 10 million copies.^[5]

To promote Under My Skin, Lavigne went on the "Live and by Surprise Tour", a 21-city mall tour in the United States and Canada. The venue in each city wasn't announced until 48 hours before the show, which began on March 5, 2004, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, the week "Don't Tell Me" was released to radio. Accompanied by her guitarist Evan Taubenfeld, Lavigne performed a short live acoustic version of five songs from the album. The set also included "Sk8er Boi" from Let Go.^[58] Selections of this tour were released on the Live Acoustic EP, which was released exclusively in Target stores.

Credits adapted from the liner notes of Under My Skin.

Musicians

Production