A 1993 survey of wargames gave V for Victory II: Velikiye Luki three-plus stars.[1]
John Vanore reviewed the game in Computer Gaming World for their April 1993 edition. He was generally very positive, stating that it was "an excellent extension of the series." He does point to some vocal criticism by players, especially over a distinct lack of aggressiveness on the part of the computer when it commands the Soviet forces, but passes this off to the Soviets having little supply. The only major complaint he had was that the game was initially not able to be played within the game engine of the earlier entries in the series, noting that the company admitted this was a mistake and was looking to fix it. He concludes that "I wholeheartedly recommend it to any Mac or DOS computer gamer."[2]
In contrast, while writing about the last instalment in the series months later in the same magazine, Terry Coleman was far less impressed. He criticized Velikiye Luki as buggy and flawed, and described the boring gameplay as "perilously close to sleepwalking."[3]
The game was awarded war game of the year by Computer Game Review.[4]