Awarding the EP three and a half stars for Jesus Freak Hideout, Michael Weaver states, "Vereor Deus Non Dogma is nowhere close to perfect, but it does offer up quite a few enjoyable moments."[5] Ian Webber, rating the EP an eight out of ten at Cross Rhythms, writes, "this short release is worth seeking out."[2] Giving the EP two stars from HM Magazine, Collin Simula says, "this EP leaves the listener wanting much more."[3]
Signaling in a three star review for Indie Vision Music, Lee Brown responds, "Mayfly brings a sound that is influenced by the past, but is perfectly timed to help shape the future of heavy music."[4] Topher Parks, indicating in a four star review at Jesus Wired, recognizes, "Vereor Deus Non Dogma has its strengths as well as its flaws".[6] Assigning the EP four stars from The Christian Music Review Blog, Brad Johnson replies, "the production quality on this EP was great, it was not excellent."[1]
