Year
Performers
Conductor
Label and number
Notes
Refs
1953 Univ of Illinois SO, The Oratorio Society Leopold Stokowski LP: Univ of Illinois CRS1 LP format only. Incomplete: items not in the usual order. Modern instruments. [ 2]
1953 Swabian Choral Singers, Stuttgart Bach Orch. Hans Grischkat LP: STUX 52004 LP format only. Based on Redlich edition; items not in the usual order. Modern instruments. [ 2]
1953 London St Anthony Singers, Oiseau-Lyre Orch Anthony Lewis LP format only. Modern instruments. [ 2]
1967 Lausanne Vocal and Instrumental Ensemble Michel Corboz LP: Erato STU 70325-7 CD (1990): Apex 2564 61429-2 (reissued, other labels) Period instruments. [ 2] [ 3]
1967 Monteverdi-Chor Hamburg , Vienna Concertus MusiciansJürgen Jürgens LP: Telefunken AWT 9501-2 CD (1994): Teldec 4509 92175-2 Period instruments. [ 2] [ 3]
1967 Gregg Smith Singers, Texas Boys Choir of Fort Worth, Colombia Baroque Ensemble Robert Craft LP: Columbia M2L 363 CD (1996): Sony 62656 Items in not in the usual order. Modern instruments. [ 4]
1967 Deller Consort , French National Radio Choir and OrchestraMaurice Le Roux LP: Concert Hall Soc. SMS 2518 CD (1988): Adès OR13.270-2 Modern instruments. [ 4]
1967 Ambrosian Singers , Orch. of the Accademia MonteverdianaDenis Stevens LP: Vanguard VCS 10001/2 LP format only. Stevens edition, replaces concertos with plainchant antiphons. Modern instruments. [ 4]
1968 Polifonica Ambrosiana Choir and Orchestra Giuseppe Biella LP: Musica Antiqua Sacra PAB 1306/07 LP format only. Omits concertos [ 4]
1970 Berlin Radio Ensemble, Berlin Chamber Orchestra Helmut Koch LP: Eterna 8 26056/7 LP format only. Based on an edition by Walter Goehr – omits both Magnificats. Modern instruments. [ 4]
1975 Monteverdi Choir and Orchestra, Philip Jones Brass Ensemble , Salisbury Cathedral Choir , David Munrow Recorder EnsembleJohn Eliot Gardiner LP: Decca SET593/4 CD (1986): Decca 414 573/4-2, (reissued) Modern instruments. [ 3] [ 4]
1975 Regensburg Cathedral Choir and Instrumental Ensemble Hanns-Martin Schneidt LP: Archiv 2710 017 CD (1996): Archiv 447 719-2 Based on edition of Gottfried Wolters . Period instruments. [ 3] [ 5]
1975 Pacifica Singers, Musica Pacifica Paul Vorwerk LP: Musica Pacifica PCFM 1002 LP format only. Period instruments. [ 5]
1976 Early Music Consort of London , King's College Choir, Cambridge Philip Ledger LP: EMI ASD3256/7 CD (1995): EMI 7243 5 68632/3 (reissued) Based on an edition by Denis Arnold . Period instruments. [ 3] [ 5]
1976 Chapel Choirs of Musics Montserrat, Collegium Aureum Irenu Segarra LP: Harmonia Mundi 1C 165-99 681-82 LP format only. Period instruments. [ 5]
1980 Aachen Cathedral Choir and Orchestra Rudolf Pohl LP:Interdisc ID602 LP format only. [ 5]
1980 Pro Cantione Antiqua , Hannover Boys' Choir , Collegium Aureum , Musica FiatHeinz Hennig LP: Interdisc ID603 CD (1991): Ars Musici AM1000-2 (reissued) Period instruments. [ 3] [ 5] [ 6]
1981 Les Petits Chanteurs de Chaillot, La Grande Ecurie et la Chambre du Roy , Vocal Ensemble Roger Thirot, Choir School Notre Dame, Les Sacquboutiers de Toulouse Jean-Claude Malgoire LP: CBS Masterworks D2 36943 CD (2012): Sony G0100027508299 Period instruments [ 7] [ 8]
1983 Vocal Ensemble of Lausanne, Schola des Petits Chanteurs de Notre Dame de Sion, Ensemble of Ancient Instruments Michel Corboz LP: Erato NUM75030/1 CD (1983): Erato ECD 2292-45183-2 (reissued) Period instruments. [ 3] [ 7] [ 8]
1983 The Harvard-Radcliffe Collegium Musicum, Baroque Orchestra, NY Cornet and Sacbut Ensemble Jameson Marvin LP: Titanic 120/121 LP format only. Period instruments. [ 7]
1984 Taverner Consort and Players Andrew Parrott EMI CDC 7 47078/9 (reissued) Period instruments [ 3] [ 7] [ 8]
1986 Tölz Boys' Choir , Vienna Hofburgkapelle Schola [ de ] , Vienna ConcertusNikolaus Harnoncourt WCJ 2564 69464-8 (reissued) Period instruments [ 3] [ 8]
1986 La Chapelle Royale, Collegium Vocale Gent and Les Saqueboutiers de Toulouse Philippe Herreweghe Harmonia Mundi HMX290 1247-8 (reissued) Period instruments [ 3] [ 8]
1988 The Sixteen Choir and Orchestra Harry Christophers Hyperion 66311/2 (reissued) Period instruments. Recast as Vespers of St Barbara, with text and musical arrangements [ 3] [ 9]
1989 La Capella Reial, Coro del Centro Musica Antica di Padova Jordi Savall Auvidis Astrée E8719 (reissued) Period instruments [ 3] [ 9]
1989 Musica Fiata Köln, Stuttgart Chamber Choir, Choralschola Niederalteich Frieder Bernius DHM RD77760 (reissued) Period instruments [ 3] [ 9]
1989 New London Consort Philip Pickett L'Oiseau-Lyre 425 823-2OH2 (reissued) [ 3] [ 8]
1989 The Monteverdi Choir, The London Oratory Junior Choir, His Majestys Sagbutts & Cornetts , The English Baroque Soloists John Eliot Gardiner Archiv 429 565-2AH2 (reissued) Second recording by Gardiner [ 3] [ 8]
1993 The Scholars Baroque Ensemble Naxos 8 550662/3 [ 3] [ 8]
1994 Cantus Cölln, Concerto Palatino Konrad Junghänel Deutsche HM G01100009381079 (reissued) [ 3] [ 8]
1995 Vokalensemble Frankfurt, Instumentalensemble "Il basso" Ralf Otto Capriccio C10516 [ 8]
1996 Netherland Chamber Choir, Concerto Vocale René Jacobs : Harmonia Mundi HMC90 1566/7 Period instruments [ 3] [ 10]
1996 London Bach Orchestra, London Cornett & Sackbutt Ensemble Louis Halsey BBC Records 156569187-7 Period instruments. Recorded 25 May 1970. [ 10]
1996 Dresden Chamber Choir, Early Music Consort of Dresden, Wind Collegium of Leipzig Hans-Christoph Rademann Raumklang 9605 Period instruments. Based on Wolters edition [ 10]
1997 Boston Baroque Orchestra Martin Pearlman Telarc 2CD80453 [ 3] [ 10]
1997 Les Arts Florissants Orchestra and Chorus , Les Sacqueboutiers de ToulouseWilliam Christie Erato 3984 23139-2 (reissued) [ 3] [ 8]
1998 Coro della Radio Svizzera, Ensemble More Antiquo, Concerto Palatino, I Barocchisti Diego Fasolis Arts 47594-9 [ 3]
1999 Verso Chorus, Madrigalia Choir, Elyma Ensemble Gabriel Garrido K617 K617 100 (reissued) [ 3] [ 8]
1999 Bach Collegium Japan , Concerto PalatinoMasaaki Suzuki BIS BIS-CD1071/2 (reissued) [ 3] [ 8]
1999 Zagreb Radio Choir, Zagreb Philharmonic Orchestra Lovro von Matačić Living Stage LS1035 Live recording 5 June 1974 [ 8]
2002 Tragicomedia, Concerto Palatino Stephen Stubbs ATMA Classique ACD22304/5 [ 3]
2004 Concerto Italiano Rinaldo Alessandrini Naïve OP30403 (reissued) [ 3] [ 8]
2004 Yorkshire Bach Choir Peter Seymour Cloister CLOCD0304 [ 3]
2005 Gabrieli Consort and Players Paul McCreesh Archiv 477 6147AH2 (reissued) [ 3] [ 8]
2006 The King's Consort Choir and Orchestra Robert King Hyperion CDA67531/2 [ 3]
2007 New York's Grande Bande Frederick Renz Musical Heritage Society 523536W Period instruments
2007 Southern Sinfonia, Rodolfus Choir, The English Cornet & Sackbut Ensemble Ralph Allwood Signum SIGCD109 Period instruments [ 3]
2007 La Petite Bande Sigiswald Kuijken Challenge Classics CC72311 [ 3]
2008 Soloists, chorus and orchestra (unspecified) Eugen Jochum Andromeda ANDRCD9031 Live recording 6 September 1957 [ 8]
2010 Ensemble Concerto, Ensemble la Pifarescha, Concerto Palatino Roberto Gini Dynamic CDS656/1-3 [ 8]
2010 New College Choir Oxford , Charivari AgréableEdward Higginbottom novum NCR1382 [ 8]
2010 Apollo's Fire Jeannette Sorrell Avie AV2206 [ 8]
2011 Choir and Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment Robert Howarth Signum SIGCD237 [ 8]
2011 L'Arpeggiata Christina Pluhar Erato 6419942 [ 8]
2011 Musica Fiata Roland Wilson Pan Classics PC10240 [ 8]
2012 Concerto Palatino, Himlische Cantorey, Hanover Boys Choir, Vox Werdensis, Musica Alta Ripa Jörg Breiding Rondeau ROP7012-13 [ 8]
2013 Western Michigan University Chorale, Seraphic Fire Patrick Dupré Quigley Seraphic Fire Media SFMCD06 [ 8]
2014 Choeur de Chambre de Namur, Cappella Mediterranea Leonardo García Alarcón Ambronay AMY041 [ 8]
2014 The Sixteen Harry Christophers Coro 16126 Second recording by The Sixteen [ 8]
2014 amarcord, Lautten Compagney Wolfgang Katschner Carus CARUS83394 [ 8] [ 11]
2016 Ensemble San Felice, La Pifaresca period brass ensemble Federico Bardazzi Brilliant Classics 95188BR [ 8]
2017 Dunedin Consort, His Majestys Sagbutts & Cornetts John Butt Linn CKD569 [ 8]
2017 Cantar Lontano Marco Mencoboni Pan Classics PC10371 [ 8]
2017 La Compagnia del Madrigale, Cantica Symphonia, La Pifarescha Giuseppe Maletto Glossa GCD922807 [ 8]
2018 Collegium Vocale Gent Philippe Herreweghe Phi Second recording by Herreweghe and Collegium Vocale Gent
[ 12]
2019 La Tempête Simon-Pierre Bestion Alpha 552 [ 13]
2023 Pygmalion Raphaël Pichon Harmonia Mundi 902710.11 [ 14]