When We Were Small

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
Allmusic	[1]
Metro Times	[2]
Pitchfork Media	7.3/10[3]

Pitchfork Media rated the album 7.3 out of 10, with reviewer Brad Haywood calling it "a solid debut, long on talent but maybe a bit short on melody or lacking in appropriate production".^[3] Allmusic awarded it four stars, with Tom Semioli calling it a "mesmerizing debut outing".^[1] Indy Week described it as "a quiet collection of songs that tend to spotlight the lyrics, and in Thomas' case, that's definitely a plus".^[4] Geoffrey Himes, writing for the Washington Post, commented on Thomas's "frail, breathy soprano that offers reluctant confessions over minimalist keyboard settings".^[5]

All songs written by Rosie Thomas.

1. "2 Dollar Shoes" – 3:10
2. "Farewell" – 3:12
3. "Wedding Day" – 5:26
4. "Lorraine" – 3:24
5. "Finish Line" – 2:40
6. "October" – 2:21
7. "I Run" – 4:07
8. "Charlotte" – 3:19
9. "Have You Seen My Love?" – 2:56
10. "Bicycle Tricycle" – 6:04