Andy Hardy Meets Debutante

Andy Hardy from Carvel becomes infatuated with well-known young socialite Daphne Fowler, from New York City. Although he has never met Daphne, he tells his friend "Beezy" and on-and-off girlfriend Polly Benedict that he and Daphne know each other well and hints that she has a romantic interest in him.

Andy's father, judge James K. Hardy, travels to New York with the whole family to work on a case involving an orphanage. The judge must appear in court against a law firm that is disputing payments from a trust fund that supports the orphanage. Polly and Beezy, editors of the monthly Carvel High School magazine, still don't believe Andy knows Daphne and tell him they plan to print a story about his relationship with Daphne, forcing him to pursue her to avoid embarrassment. In New York, Andy encounters old friend Betsy Booth, who has had a longtime crush on him. Andy remains oblivious to Betsy's feeling for him while he attempts to meet the popular and seemingly unattainable Daphne.

Andy attempts to hand deliver a letter to Daphne but is intercepted by her mother who politely dismisses him. Andy hears on the radio that Daphne is to attend a function at a posh restaurant. Betsy tries to warn him that the restaurant is quite expensive but Andy is certain that the $8 he has will be enough. He visits the restaurant to wait for Daphne, orders dinner and is incredulous when he discovers his bill for dinner is $37.25 (now equivalent to $865.40). After chastising Andy for putting on airs, the restaurant manager sends him away and declines to call the police.

Meanwhile, Judge Hardy wins the orphanage case. Andy is inspired by his father's successful litigation, and in a moment of honesty, he tells Betsy about his situation. Coincidentally, Betsy is a friend of Daphne and she immediately arranges for Andy to meet her.^[2]

Andy finds the high-society life too expensive and realizes his feelings for Betsy. They have their first kiss and they promise to write to each other regularly.

• Alone
  • Music by Nacio Herb Brown
  • Lyrics by Arthur Freed
  • Played on a record and sung by Judy Garland

• I'm Nobody's Baby
  • Written by Benny Davis, Milton Ager and Lester Santley
  • Sung by Judy Garland at the party