No Good Deed (song)

Performed towards the end of Act Two, the song springs from Elphaba's rage over her continuously thwarted efforts to do good and her inner turmoil about her intention for doing so. It explores the ideas of goodness and wickedness that are central to the musical's theme. "No Good Deed" is sung while Elphaba believes Glinda has used her sister's death to lure Elphaba into being captured by the Wizard's Guard. Elphaba is distraught at being vilified by the Wizard's propaganda and the hatred of the citizens of Oz, so she decides she will no longer attempt to do good.

In the song, Elphaba lists what she perceives as her failures at goodness, including anger with herself over her love interest Fiyero, who is being tortured by the Wizard's guards in hopes he will reveal her whereabouts; the capture and incapacitation of her favorite teacher, Dr. Dillamond; and the death of her sister, Nessarose. It begins with Elphaba screaming "Fiyero," but instead of an unhitched scream, she sings a high note that is a minor second above the tonal centre of the song. This creates the effect of a scream, as the note is very high and dissonant, but is much more controlled and musical than an actual scream.^[2] It then moves into a chant of magical words making it the most chilling and foreboding of all the musical's numbers.

Schwartz has likened "No Good Deed" to an opera aria:

"It’s just written for a different voice type, and it’s not written to be sung amplified. So those are the two big differences. I mean, 'No Good Deed' is written for a belter—I suppose a mezzo-soprano could sing it. But the orchestra is so busy and obstreperous throughout that you have to have an amplified voice to carry over it, if you want to hear the words at all. But for instance there's a moment in 'No Good Deed' where she belts a big note and then there's a place where it suddenly gets pianissimo — she has to hit the note very loud and hold it, and then get very soft — and that's absolutely like something one would write in classical singing or an opera aria. Or the moment where she does 'Nessa, Dr. Dillamond,' and then sort of shouts out 'Fiyero' while the orchestra is sawing away at one of the motifs. I think it's structured very much like an aria but it's built to get a great big hand at the end with a big belted last note. So it's still very much musical theatre."^[3]

Originally, it was sung by actress Idina Menzel, who is known for, as Ben Brantley of the New York Times describes it, her "iron strong larynx". Stephen Schwartz composed it specifically to showcase Menzel's belting talent, in addition to giving her a second-act solo song. Idina Menzel has been quoted as saying that this song was her favorite to sing in the show as it "reminded her of her Bat Mitzvah."^{[citation needed]}