User talk:Nthep

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Copyvio advice

Hey Nthep, saw you declined the revdel requests at barm and barm cake. I understood that the majority of the source being copied into Wikipedia would fall awry of WP:COPYQUOTE, which prohibits a "substantial portion" being quoted. Do you not think this was a significant portion, or do you have any advice to offer for when it is appropriate to request revdel for excessive quotations? Whonting (talk) 05:53, 28 June 2026 (UTC)

@Whonting it's a balancing act. I agree that WP:COPYQUOTE is entirely applicable in this case and I think you were entirely correct in removing an excessive quotation. However WP:REVDEL says that copyright violations should only be applied when there is a blatant breach of copyright. Here there was no attempt to pass the quote of as original work, indeed it was fully cited, so it wasn't blatant in that respect. The amount of disruption caused to the article history also has to be considered. If I had applied revdel, that would be three years worth of revisions affected to barm and nine years worth to barm cake. In itself neither is a massive amount but still something to be considered. If either was revdel of a single edit I might have decided differently but looking at various factors I didn't think revdel was appropriate on these occasions. It was borderline though.
I'd say it is always appropriate to tag an article for revdel if you think it's applicable, the worst possible case is that the reviewing admin doesn't agree. At least it's had two sets of eyes look at it. That's a better worst possible case than not asking. Nthep (talk) 06:52, 28 June 2026 (UTC)
Thanks, this is very helpful and I appreciate you writing it up. Whonting (talk) 06:54, 28 June 2026 (UTC)

Wikidata weekly summary #738

More information Extended content ...
Close

WikiProject Yorkshire Newsletter - July 2026

Delivered 1 July 2026 by MediaWiki message delivery.
If you do not wish to receive the newsletter, please add an N to the column against your username on the Project Mainpage.

19:29, 1 July 2026 (UTC)

Administrators' newsletter – July 2026

News and updates for administrators from the past month (June 2026).

Administrator changes

added
removed

CheckUser changes

readded
removed

Oversight changes

readded
removed L235

Guideline and policy news

Technical news

Arbitration

Miscellaneous


Sent by MediaWiki message delivery (talk) 14:07, 2 July 2026 (UTC)

Wikidata weekly summary #739

The Signpost: 13 July 2026

Wikidata weekly summary #740

Stefan Hoops

Books & Bytes – Issue 75

Wikidata weekly summary 741

Wikidata weekly summary #742

Related Articles

Wikiwand AI